Zombieland put up a spirited defense, but alas, the flesh eaters from Dawn of the Dead ended up overwhelming the new comedy, and tearing it to pieces. That means, Zombieland has placed fourth just behind 28 Days Later. Now it is time to determine who wins it all and who walks away second best.

Night of the Living Dead versus Dawn of the Dead (2004)

Here is Night of the Living Dead’s synopsis:

Chaos descends upon the world as the brains of the recently deceased become inexplicably reanimated, causing the dead to rise and feed on human flesh. Speculation rests on a radiation-covered NASA satellite returning from Venus, but it only remains a speculation. Anyone who dies during the crisis of causes unrelated to brain trauma will return as a flesh-eating zombie, including anyone who has been bitten by a zombie. The only way to destroy the zombies is to destroy the brain. As the catastrophe unfolds, a young woman visiting her father’s grave takes refuge in a nearby farmhouse, where she is met by a man who protects her and barricades them inside. They both later discover people hiding in the basement, and they each attempt to cope with the situation. Their only hope rests on getting some gasoline from a nearby pump into a truck that is running on empty, but this requires braving the hordes of ravenous walking corpses outside. When they finally put their plans into action, panic and personal tensions only add to the terror as they try to survive.

Here is Dawn of the Dead’s synopsis:

The feature-film debut of director Zack Snyder, Dawn of the Dead is a modern retelling of George Romero’s 1978 horror classic, which was actually the second film in a trilogy that began with Night of the Living Dead and concluded with Day of the Dead. Sarah Polley and Ving Rhames star as two of the last remaining people on an earth that has been ravaged by flesh-eating zombies. After escaping to a shopping mall with a handful of other survivors, they decide that they only way to truly elude the approaching throng of undead is to somehow make their way to an island that is supposedly zombie-free. Jake Weber and Mekhi Phifer also star. ~ Matthew Tobey, All Movie Guide

So which is the better zombie film?

Updated Zombie Bracket (special thanks to Matt for some zombie bracket corrections)